Skip to content

After veto, City leaders talk redistricting again

By Randy Bell

After veto, City leaders talk redistricting again

Check out a podcast version of this story on our YouTube Channel.

Clinton’s Board of Aldermen had its first opportunity October 3 to try to override Mayor Phil Fisher’s veto of a redistricting map adopted at the previous Board meeting, but the issue never came up.

“We think there could be a better plan out there,” said Ward 5’s Beverly Oliver, following the meeting, which was cut short to allow City leaders to attend Neighborhood Night Out block parties that were being held across Clinton. Oliver was one of four Board members who voted September 19 in favor of a ward map the local NAACP had submitted as an alternative to six other plans which had been drawn up.

Despite their differences, Oliver is optimistic that the Board can reach an agreement.

“I’m hoping that after all of this, everyone will come to the table, and I think we could do it,” Oliver said.

Fisher objected to the proposal known as Plan 7, approved on a 4-3 vote, saying, “I do not believe the ward map that was adopted is in the best interest of the City.” It would have taken five votes to override his veto.

“There’s seven plans,” the mayor noted as he prepared to hurry to his first block party. “[The Board] has to vote. That’s what they’re hired to do. Stalling the vote and trying to come up with an eighth plan—I just don’t know where they’re going to come up with one that makes sense and has logic to it without complete fruit basket turnover.”

Ward 4’s Chip Wilbanks was among three Board members who voted for a different redistricting map (Plan 3), complaining that Plan 7 made dramatic changes in Ward 4.

Oliver said Plan 3 did the same thing in her ward (5). But Wilbanks shares Oliver’s hope that progress can be made.

“I believe we’ll get a plan,” said Wilbanks. “I hope maybe we’ll have it on the agenda the first meeting of November. If they come up with [another] plan, I’ll be glad to look at it.”

But Wilbanks says he doesn’t know of any other city that’s had seven redistricting plans.

“There’s just so many ways you can maneuver things,” he said.

Ward 1’s Karen Godfrey, who also voted for Plan 3, says it’s unlikely the entire Board will agree on one map.

“We will have another vote,” said Godfrey. “I think the hope is for a complete consensus, which I don’t think there will be.”

Even though redistricting was never mentioned at the October 3 meeting, the issue prompted a lively discussion at the Board’s work session the night before.

Alderwoman-at-Large Ricki Garrett suggested that existing maps be “tweaked” to try to create a plan that they all could accept. Garrett had voted for Plan 7.

Ward 2’s Jim Martin, who also voted for Plan 7, said there are “fallacies” in all of the maps. He admitted he didn’t like either of the two plans receiving votes September 19, and he was “very pleased” the Mayor vetoed the Board’s action. Garrett said neither map (3 or 7) is “the right plan for Clinton.”

The 2020 census indicated a shift in the City’s population, which means that the lines must be redrawn before the next municipal elections in order to rebalance the six wards.

 

Leave a Comment