Skip to content

Board approves gallery expansion, despite objections

By Randy Bell

Wyatt Waters recently received approval to expand his Olde Towne Clinton gallery.

Wyatt Waters recently received approval to expand his Olde Towne Clinton gallery.

Wyatt Waters has been given the go-ahead to add a second story to his art gallery in Olde Towne Clinton—even though the Mississippi Department of Archives and History (MDAH), the City’s Planning and Zoning Review Board, Clinton’s Historic Preservation Commission and Mayor Phil Fisher all believe it’s a bad idea.

Wyatt and Kristi Waters had applied for a certificate of appropriateness for the project and dimensional variances to allow the balcony to extend over the City’s right of way on Jefferson Street and to permit a sign that’s larger than normally allowed. The Board of Aldermen gave its unanimous approval at its meeting on July 18.

Waters says he’s run out of room in his existing gallery, and upward is the only direction he can expand.

“It would be the same footprint,” the renowned watercolorist says. “Eleven hundred square feet is what we have.”

Kristi Waters says it’ll be similar to buildings seen in places like Brookhaven, Oxford and Bay St. Louis.

“It would have that look,” she says. “It would work within the architecture feel of Olde Towne. It wouldn’t be a disruption. But it fits our business objective of doubling our space.”

She says they’ve made every effort to convince historic preservation officials to sign off on the project.

“We have gone nine ways to Sunday trying to figure out a way to work in partnership with Archives and History.” But she says the department made it clear it would never okay a second story addition to the building at 307 Jefferson.

The Board approved the project after several members said they would hate to lose the gallery to another community, which Waters says would have been his only other choice.

“We don’t have any more room to grow. And, if you don’t grow, you die,” he said. “That’s how it is.”

The gallery has been in Clinton’s historic district for twenty-five years.

“I know a lot about Olde Towne,” Waters says. “I like the community of businesses that are there. I wouldn’t do anything that would hurt the momentum that we have going.”

He believes people come to Olde Towne to shop and dine mainly because of the “visual charm” of the area.

“I think [the gallery project] would be a very positive thing for continuing that.”

Rendering showing what the expansion of the gallery will look like.

Rendering showing what the expansion of the gallery will look like.

Mayor Fisher disagrees. He says he’s concerned that the building, which dates back to 1948, will no longer be considered a contributing element in Clinton’s Olde Towne National Register Historic District. And he says that could threaten the District’s hard-earned designation, which was achieved in 2017.

“It is a big deal,” Fisher says. “When you have a legitimate historic district, you need to really treasure that. This is our center of gravity, so to speak. And without that center of gravity, we’re just another town on Highway 80.”

The mayor says Olde Towne is being dismantled, “piece by piece.”

Fisher is a big fan of Waters’ work and says he’s bought more of his art than the entire Board of Aldermen combined. But, he says, “I believe in historic preservation and keeping it as it is. And I can tell you, it won’t be long before somebody else is going to come up and say, ‘You did it for him. You’re not going to let me put a second story up there?’”

MDAH voiced several objections to the project. In a letter to the City, the department’s Chief of Preservation Planning Meredith Massey wrote that “the proposed changes would not retain the historic character of this storefront.”

She said adding the second story would give the property “a different appearance from the existing building,” one which “does not differentiate the old from the new,” making it look like a brand new design. Massey also wrote that the alterations would be “seemingly permanent, or at least incredibly hard to reverse.”



 

Leave a Comment